Op-ed: UCLA must adopt institutional neutrality to protect free, diverse speech
By Bruin Alumni in Defense of Free Speech
Aug. 19, 2024 10:28 p.m.
Editor’s note: The following letter was sent to Darnell Hunt, UCLA’s interim chancellor, on Aug. 9 on behalf of Bruin Alumni in Defense of Free Speech. A full list of individuals who have signed on to the letter is included at the end of the submission.
Dear Chancellor Hunt:
We at Bruin Alumni in Defense of Free Speech are writing to ask that UCLA adopt a commitment to institutional neutrality similar to the University of Chicago’s Kalven Report of 1967. We ourselves are not neutral in our individual political views and neither are students and faculty at UCLA. But for that very reason we urge the university itself to remain neutral. This will allow discourse to flourish on campus and allow students and faculty to engage in debates on contemporary issues, free from institutional pressure.
In recent years, colleges and universities have increasingly weighed in on social and political issues. This has led our institutions of higher education to become politicized and has created an untenable situation where they are expected to weigh in on all social and political issues.
Most critically, sharing institutional stances on these issues risks establishing an orthodox view on campus, chilling the speech of those who disagree. This threatens the pursuit of knowledge that higher education exists to facilitate.
As the Kalven Report argues, a policy of institutional neutrality is premised on the defining mission of the university: to pursue truth through “the discovery, improvement, and dissemination of knowledge.” To accomplish this mission, “a university must sustain an extraordinary environment of freedom of inquiry and maintain an independence from political fashions, passions, and pressures.”
In recent weeks, Harvard, Syracuse, Stanford and Purdue Universities have all adopted an institutional neutrality statement to protect free expression and viewpoint diversity on campus. Please take this important step and signal to students and faculty that UCLA is a place where all are welcome to share their views and where any idea can be debated without fear. Thank you for your consideration as we strive to make the educational experience at UCLA the best it can be.
Sincerely,
Jerald L. Mosley
Co-founder of Bruin Alumni in Defense of Free Speech
UCLA Alum ’82
Dominic Manser
Co-founder of Bruin Alumni in Defense of Free Speech
UCLA Alum 2014
In support:
Earl Altshuler
UCLA Alum ’72
Arlette Baljon
Parent of UCLA Alum; Professor, San Diego State University Dept. of Physics
John Bickle
UCLA Alum ’83; Professor, Mississippi State University Dept. of Philosophy and
Religion; Scientist-Educator, University of Mississippi Medical Center
Bette Billet
UCLA Alum ’66
Walter E. Block
Eminent Scholar and Professor, Loyola University New Orleans College of Business
Richard Brannin
UCLA Alum ’74
Pamela Bumerts
Laboratory Manager at Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center (retired)
Aaron A. Burke
Professor, UCLA Department of Near Eastern Languages & Cultures
Li Cai
Professor, UCLA School of Education and Information Studies and Dept. of Psychology
John Carlton
UCLA Alum ’79
Americo Cascella
UCLA Alum ’94
David Churchman
UCLA Alum ’72; Professor Emeritus, California State Dominguez Hills College of
Natural and Behavioral Sciences
John Coons
Professor Emeritus, UC Berkeley School of Law
Stephen Cox
UCLA Alum ’76; Distinguished Professor Emeritus, UC San Diego Dept. of Literature
Sunnie Daniels
UCLA Alum ’96
Richard V. Eastin
Associate Professor Emeritus, USC Marshall School of Business
James E. Enstrom
UCLA Alum ’76; Research Professor, UCLA Dept. of Epidemiology (retired)
Peter M. Felker
Professor Emeritus, UCLA Dept. of Chemistry and Biochemistry
Charles Geshekter
UCLA Alum ’72; Professor Emeritus, CSU, Chico, Dept. of History
Kevin Gilligan
UCLA Alum ’90
Oleg Gleizer
Director of UCLA Olga Radko Endowed Math Circle
Stephen H. Haber
UCLA Alum ’85; Professor, Stanford University Depts. of Political Science, History and Economics
Daniel Hepler
Senior Lecturer, UC Riverside Writing Program
Roger Janeway
UCLA Alum ’94
Jon Jenkins
Parent of UCLA Alum
Jack Katz
Research Professor, UCLA Dept. of Sociology
Dean S. Kaufman
UCLA Alum ’66
Daniel B. Klein
Professor, George Mason University Department of Economics
Joel D. Kopple
Professor Emeritus, UCLA Dept. of Medicine
Mitchell Langbert
UCLA alum ’81; Associate Professor, Brooklyn College of CUNY School of Business (retired)
Michel L. Lapidus
Distinguished Professor, UC Riverside Dept. Mathematics
Tom Leeson
Visiting Assistant Professor 1993-1994, UCLA Department of Design
Geoffrey Marcy
UCLA Alum ’76; Professor Emeritus, UC Berkeley Dept. of Astronomy
James E. Moore
Professor Emeritus, USC Dept. of Industrial and Systems Engineering
Paul Nachman
Staff Scientist, TRW/Northrop Grumman, 1985-1989 and 1996-2005
Lee Ohanian
Distinguished Professor, UCLA Dept. of Economics
Joe Piechowski
UCLA Alum ’94
Kristofer Pister
Professor, UC Berkeley Dept. Electrical Engineering and Computer Sciences
J. Mark Ramseyer
Professor, Harvard Law School
Stephanie Reynolds
UCLA Alum ’93; Parent of UCLA Student
Gary W. Roemer
UCLA Alum ’99
J. Thomas Rosenthal
Professor Emeritus, UCLA School of Medicine
Gabriel Rossman
UCLA Alum ’99; Professor, UCLA Dept. of Sociology
Sam Roth
UCLA Alum 2021
Jerome Rotter
UCLA Alum ’73; Distinguished Professor, UCLA School of Medicine
Sherry Sanvictores
UCLA Alum 2002
Barry Schein
Professor, USC Dept. of Linguistics and Philosophy
Allen W. Shafter
UCLA Alum ’83
David Shulman
UCLA Alum ’75; Visiting Scholar, UCLA Anderson School
Harvey A. Silverglate
Co-founder and current member of the Board of Directors of The Foundation for
Individual Rights and Expression
Desmond J. Smith
Professor, UCLA School of Medicine
Michael Wesley Suman
UCLA Alum ’92; Continuing Lecturer, UCLA Department of Communication
Demetri Terzopoulos
Distinguished Professor, UCLA Dept. of Computer Science
Frank P. Tomasulo
UCLA Alum ’86; Professor of Graduate Film Studies, National University
Daniel Treisman
Professor, UCLA Dept. of Political Science
Stanley W. Trimble
Professor Emeritus, UCLA Dept. of Geography
Eugene Volokh
UCLA Alum ’92; Distinguished Professor Emeritus, UCLA School of Law
Bob Waldorf
UCLA Alum ’62; Parent of UCLA Alum
Toby Waldorf
UCLA Alum ’80; Parent of UCLA Alum
Eugene Ward
UCLA Alum ’76
Randy O. Wayne
UCLA Alum ’79
Ted Weggeland
UCLA Alum ’81
Ralph D. Westfall
UCLA Alum ’66; Professor Emeritus, California Polytechnic University Pomona Dept.
of Computer Information Systems
Richard W. White, Jr.
Adjunct Faculty, UC School of Social Welfare 1978-1982
Erik Wolfers
Parent of UCLA Student
Ruicheng Yan
UCLA Alum 2016
Alyssa Ziman
UCLA Alum ’93; Professor, UCLA School of Medicine
Helene Ziman
UCLA Alum ’72
Benjamin M. Zuckerman
Professor Emeritus, UCLA Dept. of Physics & Astronomy