Monday, September 24

Campus Queries: Can ancestry tests provide information about racial, ethnic identity?


(Jessie Hui/Daily Bruin)

(Jessie Hui/Daily Bruin)


Campus Queries is a series in which Daily Bruin readers and staff present science-related questions for UCLA professors and experts to answer.

Q: To what extent can genetic ancestry tests be significant in providing information on racial and ethnic identity?

A: Genetic ancestry tests are used to investigate one’s genealogy, which can subsequently reveal information such as family history, ethnic makeup and diseases one is at risk for. Laboratory technicians can run tests on samples of bodily tissue or fluid to compare the DNA with a database of other human genomes, looking for patterns of genetic similarities among ethnic groups or families.

The tests are limited in their scientific accuracy to providing information about ethnic backgrounds and family lineage because research has shown genetic differences among people of various races to be statistically negligible. The genetic databases that different genetic ancestry testers use may also vary.

Researchers in the social sciences have begun to study how individuals use ancestry tests to validate their racial identities.

Aaron Panofsky, an associate professor of public policy, said genetic ancestry tests can impact how individuals perceive their own racial identity. Panofsky has co-authored a study on white nationalists’ reactions to their genetic ancestry test results.

In his study, Panofsky said he found some white nationalists dismissed their genetic ancestry results because they showed they had varied ethnic backgrounds. Others said they thought the variation in ancestry was due to the historical colonization of indigenous communities.

“The whole idea of white DNA and nonwhite DNA is a racist myth,” Panofsky said. “(White nationalists) just assume that white and black are coherent groups. And that is a fallacious assumption – they don’t even think about it as racist.”

Panofsky said another study conducted by a researcher in Columbia University showed that African-Americans used the genetic ancestry test to assert their identities in various political movements. Another study showed that genetic ancestry tests undermined Native Americans’ sense of tribal belonging because their genealogies alone did not represent their identities.

Panofsky said he thinks genetic ancestry testing will likely put individuals who have outdated perceptions on racial purity and differences in conflict with those who are finding new ways to define race and ethnicity.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someoneShare on Google+Share on Reddit

Comments are supposed to create a forum for thoughtful, respectful community discussion. Please be nice. View our full comments policy here.